TRW & Co · Commercial contracts

Sanctions and Contract Performance: Is Payment Still Due?

Updated 20 October 2026Legal insightSingapore10 min read
Aerial view of a Singapore container terminal with gantry cranes, illustrating sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore
Photo: Unsplash.

Payment obligations usually survive sanctions. Under Singapore law, performance is excused only by supervening illegality in the place of performance, a contractual trigger, or frustration. This guide explains how courts read sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore companies sign, why Kuvera demands an objective test, and what to check before withholding payment.

Key pointIn Kuvera v JPMorgan the Court of Appeal held that a bank's reasonable fear of sanctions exposure did not excuse payment: sanctions clauses are construed strictly and objectively, so any discretion must be written in expressly.

At a glance

01

Payment is usually absolute

Sanctions excuse payment only through supervening illegality, a clause whose trigger is objectively met, or frustration; commercial difficulty or bank reluctance alone is not enough.

02

Kuvera sets a strict test

The Court of Appeal in Kuvera [2023] SGCA 28 held sanctions clauses are strictly and objectively construed, rejecting a bank's subjective fear of exposure.

03

Place of payment matters

Under the Ralli Brothers rule, payment is suspended where it requires an act unlawful in the place of performance, so the contract's payment terms are critical.

04

No duty to accept substitutes

The UK Supreme Court in MUR Shipping [2024] UKSC 18 held reasonable endeavours did not require accepting euro payment instead of contractual US dollars.

05

Singapore implements UN sanctions

MAS administers targeted financial sanctions for financial institutions under FSMA regulations, with separate UN Act regulations binding other persons and Russia-specific financial measures.

Swipe or scroll →

The short answer: is payment still due when sanctions bite?

Usually, yes, unless the law or the contract says otherwise. Under Singapore law a payment obligation is generally treated as absolute. Sanctions excuse or suspend it only where performance would actually be illegal under an applicable law, where the contract contains a clause that covers the situation, or, rarely, where the contract is frustrated. That is why the drafting of sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore businesses sign matters so much: the clause, not commercial inconvenience, usually decides the outcome.

The case law sets a strict standard. In Kuvera Resources Pte Ltd v JPMorgan Chase Bank, NA [2023] SGCA 28, the Court of Appeal held that a sanctions clause must be strictly and objectively construed, and that a bank's reasonable fear of sanctions exposure did not justify non-payment. In England, the Supreme Court held in RTI Ltd v MUR Shipping BV [2024] UKSC 18 that a party relying on force majeure was not required to accept payment in a different currency to overcome sanctions.

As of October 2026, recent English decisions applying the long-standing Ralli Brothers rule to sanctioned payments have renewed attention on where payment is to be made. This guide explains the three legal routes to excuse performance, how courts read sanctions clauses, and what to check before you withhold payment.

Container port representing trade affected by sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore companies rely on
Sanctions disputes often arise in trade, shipping and trade finance, where payment and delivery cross several jurisdictions.

Singapore implements United Nations Security Council sanctions. According to the Monetary Authority of Singapore, financial institutions are bound by regulations made under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2022, with fines of up to S$1 million for violations, while non-financial institutions and individuals are bound by regulations under the United Nations Act. The Terrorism (Suppression of Financing) Act 2002 applies to all natural and legal persons.

Singapore has also imposed its own financial measures in relation to Russia following the invasion of Ukraine. MAS states that these apply to all financial institutions, including banks, insurers, capital markets intermediaries and payment service providers, and that digital payment token service providers must not facilitate transactions that could circumvent them.

Singapore does not generally give legal effect to other countries' unilateral sanctions. US, UK or EU sanctions may nonetheless matter commercially: banks clearing US dollars apply US rules, counterparties may be subject to them, and many contracts expressly incorporate them. That is the gap sanctions clauses are designed to fill.

Three legal routes to excuse or suspend performance

1. Supervening illegality and the Ralli Brothers rule

Under the rule in Ralli Brothers v Compañia Naviera Sota y Aznar [1920] 2 KB 287, performance is excused, or suspended in the case of payment, where it would require an act in a place where that act is unlawful. Everything turns on identifying the place of performance.

Commentary published in September 2026 highlights two 2025 English Commercial Court decisions: in Eurochem v Société Générale [2025] EWHC 1938 (Comm) the court held that bonds payable in Paris and Milan could not lawfully be paid under EU sanctions, and in Beneathco DMCC v R.J. O'Brien Ltd [2025] EWHC 3079 (Comm) it said the rule would have applied where the obligation required routing through a US correspondent bank, while distinguishing a freestanding dollar debt that can be paid without touching the US system.

English authority of this kind is likely to be persuasive in Singapore, but the outcome always depends on the governing law, the place of payment the contract specifies, and whether the payment can lawfully be made in another way the contract permits.

2. The contract: sanctions and force majeure clauses

A sanctions clause may suspend obligations, allow termination, or excuse a party from dealing with sanctioned persons. Force majeure clauses can also capture sanctions, depending on their wording. These clauses only work if they are triggered on their terms. Our force majeure guide explains how Singapore courts approach such clauses generally.

3. Frustration

A contract is frustrated where a supervening event, without the fault of either party, makes performance radically different from what was agreed. Sanctions can frustrate a contract, but the threshold is high, and courts will not find frustration where the parties foresaw and provided for the risk. Where frustration applies, the Frustrated Contracts Act 1959 deals with the consequences, including recovery of money paid before discharge and allowances for expenses and benefits received.

Comparing the routes
RouteWhat must be shownEffect on payment
Supervening illegality (Ralli Brothers)Performance requires an act that is unlawful in the place of performancePayment suspended or excused while illegality lasts
Sanctions clauseThe clause's trigger is objectively met on its exact wording (Kuvera)As the clause provides: suspension, termination or release
Force majeure clauseSanctions fall within the clause, causation and any mitigation proviso are satisfiedSuspension or release; need not accept non-contractual performance (MUR)
FrustrationPerformance radically different; risk not allocated by the contractContract ends; Frustrated Contracts Act adjusts payments
None of the aboveOnly commercial difficulty, bank reluctance or reputational concernPayment remains due; withholding risks breach

In practice, the routes are tested in order. Courts start with the contract, because parties are free to allocate sanctions risk as they wish, and only fall back on illegality or frustration where the contract is silent or its clauses are not triggered. That is why disputes about sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore courts hear tend to be won or lost on wording, notices and evidence rather than on broad arguments of principle. A party that cannot point to a clause, or to a law that makes the specific act unlawful, should assume that the obligation to pay remains.

How courts read sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore parties rely on

Kuvera is the leading Singapore authority. A bank confirming letters of credit refused to pay a complying presentation because its internal screening suggested the carrying vessel might be Syrian-owned. Its confirmation contained a sanctions clause excusing payment where documents involved a party 'listed in or otherwise subject to any applicable restriction'.

The Court of Appeal held the bank liable. The vessel was not listed, and whether it was 'otherwise subject' to a restriction was an objective question of fact, not a matter of the bank's reasonable belief or what a regulator might later decide. The bank bore the burden of justifying non-payment and failed to displace the presumption arising from the vessel's registration. The court also doubted whether such a clause sat comfortably with the commercial purpose of a letter of credit, which is to give the beneficiary an assured right to be paid.

The lesson for anyone drafting sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore courts may interpret is plain: if you want discretion based on your own risk assessment or compliance policy, the clause must say so expressly, and broad discretion may itself be challenged as inconsistent with the bargain. Clauses negotiated by both parties to the underlying transaction are more likely to be respected.

Practical point

A bank's refusal to process a payment is not, by itself, a legal excuse. Unless the contract or an applicable law makes payment unlawful, the obligation usually remains, and the payer may need to use another lawful route the contract allows. Record every attempt to pay and every refusal.

What to do when a sanctions issue hits a live contract

  1. Freeze and screen. Pause the specific transaction, not the whole relationship, and screen the counterparty, owners, vessels, banks and goods against the regimes that legally bind you and those your banks apply.
  2. Identify the governing law and place of performance. Check the governing law clause, where payment or delivery must be made, the currency and any designated account.
  3. Read the clauses literally. Apply the sanctions, force majeure, illegality, termination and notice clauses to the facts objectively, as Kuvera requires.
  4. Look for lawful alternatives. Consider whether payment can lawfully be made in a way the contract permits, or into escrow, or under a licence. Do not assume you must accept a variation the other side proposes.
  5. Notify correctly. Serve any notices the contract requires, within time and in the required form, and reserve rights.
  6. Seek licences or regulatory guidance. Where a licence regime exists, apply early; where MAS-regulated entities are involved, check MAS requirements.
  7. Plan the dispute route. Check the dispute resolution clause, whether the tribunal or court can be paid and administered, and how any award would be enforced.

Illustrative scenario: a commodity buyer's frozen payment

The following scenario is illustrative only and does not describe any real client or outcome.

A Singapore trading company buys cargo from a seller in a third country under an English-law contract, payable in US dollars to the seller's bank. After shipment, the seller's parent is designated under US sanctions. The buyer's bank refuses to process the payment, and the buyer withholds it, citing the contract's sanctions clause.

The clause excuses performance only where it would 'breach sanctions laws applicable to either party'. The buyer is a Singapore company; it is not itself bound by US sanctions, though its bank applies them. The seller argues that payment can still lawfully be made through a non-US route. On these facts the buyer's position is uncertain: it must show objectively that the clause is triggered or that payment requires an unlawful act in the place of performance.

With advice, the buyer serves a reasoned notice, offers payment into escrow pending clarification, and seeks guidance on whether a lawful non-US payment route exists. Careful drafting of sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore traders sign would have avoided much of the uncertainty by specifying which regimes count and what happens to payment.

Risks and common mistakes

Withholding payment because of reputational fear

Compliance teams understandably want to avoid any link with sanctioned parties. But a subjective concern, or a bank's refusal, is not a defence unless the contract or an applicable law makes it one. Kuvera shows that courts will not imply a broad discretion into a sanctions clause.

If the business wants the right to stop performance based on its own risk appetite, negotiate that expressly. In live disputes, separate what the law prohibits from what policy prefers, and quantify the cost of breach before deciding.

Ignoring the place and currency of payment

The Ralli Brothers rule depends on where performance must occur. Recent English cases distinguish obligations that must pass through a particular jurisdiction's banks from debts that can be paid in other ways. Parties often assume dollar payments are automatically caught by US sanctions.

Check what the contract actually requires. If it specifies an account, bank, place or currency, that may fix the place of performance; if it does not, there may be lawful alternatives you are obliged to use.

Relying on force majeure to rewrite the deal

In MUR Shipping, the UK Supreme Court held that a 'reasonable endeavours' proviso in a force majeure clause did not require the affected party to accept payment in euros instead of the contractual US dollars. The converse is also true: you cannot use force majeure to impose your own alternative performance.

Read mitigation provisos carefully, document what steps were taken, and decide quickly whether to propose a variation by agreement rather than rely on the clause. Our guide to termination rights covers the next step if the relationship cannot continue.

Using boilerplate that does not name the regimes

Many sanctions clauses refer vaguely to 'applicable sanctions'. That leaves open whether US, UK or EU sanctions apply to a Singapore company that is not legally bound by them, which is exactly the uncertainty that leads to disputes.

Good sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore companies use should name the relevant regimes, define sanctioned persons, deal with ownership and control, set notice and evidence requirements, and say what happens to payment: suspension, escrow or termination.

Cross-border angle: banks, arbitration and enforcement

Disputes over sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore companies sign rarely stay in one place. Payment chains may run through New York, London or Dubai; goods may originate in China or move through Chattogram; parties may be incorporated in the UAE or the UK. Each jurisdiction's rules on sanctions, illegality and enforcement can differ, and an award or judgment obtained in Singapore may face obstacles where it must be enforced.

Sanctions can also complicate the dispute itself, for example where a sanctioned party cannot easily pay deposits or where institutions must consider their own compliance. Choosing a neutral seat, a suitable institution and a payment mechanism for costs at the drafting stage reduces that risk. Our international arbitration practice advises on these design choices, and our sanctions and restricted trade team handles regulatory analysis.

Checklist: reviewing sanctions clauses in contracts Singapore businesses rely on

  • Name the sanctions regimes that count, including whether US, UK or EU regimes apply even if not legally binding.
  • Define sanctioned persons, including ownership and control tests.
  • State the trigger objectively, or expressly allow reliance on reasonable compliance judgments if that is the commercial intent.
  • Specify the effect on payment: suspension, escrow, alternative lawful route or termination.
  • Align the clause with force majeure, illegality, termination and notice provisions.
  • Check the place and currency of payment and whether alternatives are permitted.
  • Review existing contracts in high-risk trades using our sanctions screening guide.

For advice on a live sanctions problem or a review of your templates, speak to our contract disputes and commercial contracts teams, or contact TRW & Co. Where Singapore court or tribunal representation is required, we work alongside Singapore-qualified counsel.

Frequently asked questions

01Do sanctions automatically excuse payment under a Singapore-law contract?

No. A payment obligation generally remains due unless performance would be illegal under an applicable law in the place of performance, a contractual sanctions or force majeure clause is triggered on its terms, or the contract is frustrated. A bank's refusal to process a payment or a party's reputational concern does not, on its own, excuse performance. The Court of Appeal in Kuvera v JPMorgan held a bank liable for refusing payment based on its own sanctions screening where the clause's objective trigger was not proven.

02Does Singapore enforce US or EU sanctions?

Singapore implements UN Security Council sanctions and has imposed its own financial measures relating to Russia, but it does not generally give legal effect to other countries' unilateral sanctions. US, EU or UK sanctions may still affect a Singapore contract in practice, because banks in the payment chain apply them, counterparties may be bound by them, and many contracts expressly incorporate them. Whether they excuse performance depends on the contract's wording and the place of performance.

03What did Kuvera v JPMorgan decide about sanctions clauses?

The Court of Appeal held that a sanctions clause in a letter of credit confirmation must be strictly and objectively construed. The bank could not rely on its internal screening or its reasonable fear that a regulator might find a breach; it had to prove that the vessel was in fact subject to an applicable restriction, and it failed to do so. The court also doubted whether such a clause was consistent with the purpose of a letter of credit.

04What is the Ralli Brothers rule?

It is an English common law rule, from Ralli Brothers v Compañia Naviera Sota y Aznar [1920], that a contractual obligation is excused, or suspended in the case of payment, where performance requires doing something unlawful in the place where it must be performed. Recent English decisions in 2025 applied it to payments affected by EU and US sanctions, focusing on the contractual place of payment. Its application in any Singapore dispute will depend on the governing law and payment terms.

05Can sanctions frustrate a contract in Singapore?

They can, but the threshold is high. Frustration requires a supervening event, not caused by either party, that makes performance radically different from what was agreed. It will not apply where the contract already allocates the risk, for example through a sanctions or force majeure clause, or where the sanctions were foreseeable. If a contract is frustrated, the Frustrated Contracts Act 1959 governs the consequences, including recovery of money paid and allowances for expenses.

06What should a good sanctions clause include?

It should name the sanctions regimes that apply, define sanctioned persons including ownership and control, state an objective trigger or expressly allow reliance on reasonable compliance judgments, and specify the effect on payment, such as suspension, escrow or termination. It should align with force majeure, illegality and termination provisions and set notice requirements. Clauses negotiated by both parties to the underlying transaction are more likely to be upheld than standard terms imposed unilaterally.

Sources and official materials

  1. Kuvera Resources Pte Ltd v JPMorgan Chase Bank, NA [2023] SGCA 28 — Strict, objective construction of sanctions clauses
  2. RTI Ltd v MUR Shipping BV [2024] UKSC 18 — Force majeure, reasonable endeavours and non-contractual performance
  3. MAS: Targeted financial sanctions — UN sanctions framework and Russia-related measures
  4. Financial Services and Markets Act 2022 — Statutory basis for MAS sanctions regulations
  5. Singapore Courts: SMU case brief on Kuvera — Summary of sanctions clauses in letter of credit confirmations

General information only, current as at 20 October 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Singapore law and regulatory practice change; check current official sources and take advice on the facts of your matter.

TRW on LinkedIn & Facebook

From the firm,
this week.

Conference notes, transactions in the news and the people we work with — follow TRW & Co for the full feed.

Call the Singapore desk+880 1779 127165 WhatsApp · message usMessage our team