TRW & Co · Real estate and projects

Performance Bonds in Singapore: Stopping an Unconscionable Call

Updated 20 October 2026Legal insightSingapore10 min read
Construction cranes over a building site at low sun, context for performance bond calls in Singapore
Photo: Unsplash.

Performance bond calls in Singapore can be stopped only if the obligor shows a strong prima facie case of fraud or unconscionability. A genuine dispute is not enough, the contract may exclude the unconscionability ground, and banks pay quickly, so contractors need to read the bond, test the facts and apply for an injunction within days.

Key pointBefore arguing that a call is unfair, check whether the contract has already given up that argument: the Court of Appeal has upheld clauses limiting relief to fraud, although the beneficiary bears the burden of showing the exclusion applies.

At a glance

01

Two grounds only

Singapore courts restrain calls on fraud or unconscionability. Unconscionability is a separate ground unique to Singapore and wider than the English fraud-only approach.

02

High threshold

The obligor must show a strong prima facie case. A genuine dispute about defects, delay or valuation does not on its own make a call unconscionable.

03

Exclusion clauses

The Court of Appeal has upheld contract clauses limiting relief to fraud; the beneficiary relying on such a clause bears the burden of proving it applies.

04

Typical bond size

The Court of Appeal has observed that bonds are usually pegged at around 5% to 10% of the contract price, often equal to several progress payments.

05

Speed and candour

Applications are usually urgent and often without notice, so the applicant must give full and frank disclosure and an undertaking in damages.

Swipe or scroll →

The short answer: can a call be stopped?

Yes, but only on narrow grounds and only if you move fast. Performance bond calls in Singapore can be restrained by court injunction where the obligor shows a strong prima facie case that the call is fraudulent or unconscionable. Singapore is unusual: unlike England, it recognises unconscionability as a separate ground from fraud, which gives contractors and suppliers a real, if limited, line of defence against abusive calls.

Three points shape almost every case. First, a genuine dispute about the underlying contract is not enough; the bank's undertaking is meant to pay first and leave the argument for later. Second, the contract can exclude the unconscionability ground, and the Court of Appeal has upheld such clauses, leaving fraud as the only route. Third, the injunction is usually sought against the beneficiary, to stop it receiving payment, and timing is often measured in days.

This article explains the two exceptions, how exclusion clauses work, the injunction timetable and how to draft bonds that reduce the risk of an abusive call. For the wider dispute, see our practice page on construction disputes in Singapore.

Construction project documents relevant to performance bond calls in Singapore
A bond is a cash-flow instrument: the dispute about whether the money was owed usually comes later, in arbitration or court.

On-demand and conditional bonds: why the wording matters

A performance bond is an undertaking, usually by a bank or insurer, to pay the beneficiary (typically the employer or main contractor) up to a stated sum if the obligor (the contractor or subcontractor) fails to perform. The Court of Appeal in JBE Properties Pte Ltd v Gammon Pte Ltd [2010] SGCA 46 noted that the bonded sum is usually pegged at around 5% to 10% of the contract price, which can equal one or more progress payments and therefore matters greatly to a contractor's liquidity.

In disputes over performance bond calls in Singapore, the first step is always to read the bond. Its wording decides what the beneficiary must prove to be paid, and therefore how much room the obligor has to resist.

Common forms of performance security in Singapore projects
FormWhat triggers paymentObligor's room to resist
On-demand (unconditional) bondA written demand in the prescribed form, without proof of breach or lossOnly the fraud and unconscionability exceptions, unless the contract excludes unconscionability
Conditional (default or indemnity) bondProof of the obligor's breach and the beneficiary's loss, sometimes by certificate, judgment or awardWider: the obligor can dispute whether the conditions are met
Bond with a notice requirementA demand plus prior notice to the obligor or a certificate from a named partyCan resist a call that does not comply strictly with the stated conditions
Cash retention or depositContractual set-off or withholding by the employerContractual and statutory payment rights; no bank undertaking to restrain

Many disputes begin with a disagreement about which category a bond falls into. In JBE, the contractor argued the bond was an indemnity bond payable only on proof of loss; the court below found it was an on-demand bond, and the case turned on unconscionability. Courts construe the instrument as a whole, and labels on the cover page do not decide the point.

When courts restrain performance bond calls in Singapore: fraud and unconscionability

Fraud

Fraud is the traditional ground for resisting performance bond calls in Singapore, as it is in most common law jurisdictions. The obligor must show, to a high standard, that the beneficiary is acting dishonestly, for example by calling when it knows it has no genuine entitlement. In practice, clear evidence of dishonesty is rare at an interim stage, so fraud alone succeeds in relatively few construction cases.

Unconscionability

Singapore developed unconscionability as a separate and independent ground. The Court of Appeal confirmed it in Bocotra Construction Pte Ltd v Attorney-General [1995] 2 SLR(R) 262, and has repeatedly reaffirmed it, including in JBE Properties v Gammon and BS Mount Sophia Pte Ltd v Join-Aim Pte Ltd [2012] SGCA 28. The policy reason is that a bond can become an oppressive instrument, causing undue hardship or unwarranted economic harm to a contractor if called abusively.

As the Court of Appeal in BS Mount Sophia noted, citing earlier High Court authority, unconscionability involves unfairness, as distinct from dishonesty or fraud, or conduct so reprehensible or lacking in good faith that a court of conscience would intervene; mere breaches of contract are not enough.

The applicant must show a strong prima facie case; a mere arguable case or a genuine dispute is not enough. Examples drawn from the case law include calls based on breaches for which the beneficiary is itself responsible, calls made for an ulterior purpose such as gaining leverage in an unrelated dispute, calls plainly inconsistent with the beneficiary's own earlier position, and calls for sums grossly exceeding any arguable loss.

In JBE, the court upheld an injunction where the beneficiary called the full bond to fund rectification works whose scope appeared inflated well beyond what was needed. By contrast, a 2020 High Court decision discussed in this Clifford Chance briefing discharged an injunction because a genuine dispute about the root cause of defects did not make the call unconscionable. The line is drawn between a beneficiary pressing a disputed but genuine claim, which is allowed, and one abusing the bond, which is not.

Clauses that exclude unconscionability

Employers often insert a clause in the main contract stating that the contractor may not restrain a call on any ground except fraud. In CKR Contract Services Pte Ltd v Asplenium Land Pte Ltd [2015] SGCA 24, the Court of Appeal held that such a clause was valid. It did not oust the court's jurisdiction, because it limited the grounds of relief rather than shutting the contractor out of court, and the court saw no pressing reason of principle or policy to strike it down. The court noted that the employer could equally have demanded a cash deposit instead.

The Court of Appeal returned to the topic in Bintai Kindenko Pte Ltd v Samsung C&T Corp [2019] SGCA 39. It held that the party relying on an exclusion clause bears the burden of showing that the obligor's right to invoke unconscionability has been contractually excluded. The same decision is a reminder of a second trap: the injunction in that case should also have been discharged because the applicant failed to make full and frank disclosure at the without-notice hearing.

The practical consequence for performance bond calls in Singapore is that the first question for any obligor is not whether the call is unfair, but whether the contract has already given up the unfairness argument. Exclusion clauses of this kind, like the one in CKR, typically preserve fraud as a ground of relief, so the fraud route remains open even where unconscionability is excluded.

Practical point

Check the main contract, the subcontract and the bond itself for exclusion wording before instructing anyone to draft an affidavit. If unconscionability is excluded, the case must be framed and evidenced as fraud, which is a much harder standard; if it is not excluded, say so expressly in the application and explain why.

The injunction timetable after a call

Banks generally pay quickly on a compliant demand, so an obligor usually has very little time. The application is for an interim injunction, often first heard without notice or on short notice, under the court's general power to grant injunctions, including under the Civil Law Act 1909. Our guide to injunctions and urgent relief in Singapore explains the procedure in more detail. A typical sequence for performance bond calls in Singapore is:

  1. Same day: obtain the demand and the bond. Get copies of the call, the bond and the relevant contract clauses. Check whether the demand complies strictly with the bond's terms, because a non-compliant demand may not oblige the bank to pay.
  2. Day 1: decide whether there is a case. Test the facts against fraud and unconscionability, check for exclusion clauses, and decide whether to restrain the whole call or only the excess over any arguable loss.
  3. Day 1 to 2: assemble the evidence. Prepare an affidavit exhibiting the contract, correspondence, payment records and any expert material showing why the call is abusive. Include matters that cut against you: full and frank disclosure is mandatory on a without-notice application.
  4. Day 2 to 3: apply to court. Seek an interim injunction restraining the beneficiary from receiving payment and, where appropriate, the bank from paying. Offer an undertaking in damages and be ready to show you can honour it.
  5. Notify the bank. Serve the order on the issuing bank immediately once granted. An order that arrives after payment is of little use.
  6. Inter partes hearing. The beneficiary will usually apply to discharge. The court reassesses on fuller evidence whether a strong prima facie case of fraud or unconscionability exists.
  7. Resolve the underlying dispute. The injunction preserves the position only. The merits proceed in arbitration or court, and the bond may be extended by agreement or order while that happens.

The Court of Appeal has identified a call for a sum well in excess of the beneficiary's actual or potential loss as a classic source of unwarranted harm, because any excess may be unrecoverable if the beneficiary later becomes insolvent. Evidence that quantifies the beneficiary's realistic loss is therefore one of the most useful exhibits in an application.

Drafting bonds to limit abusive calls

The cheapest injunction is the one you never need. Most abusive performance bond calls in Singapore are made possible by loose drafting at tender stage. Contractors and subcontractors negotiating performance security should focus on the instrument and the underlying contract together, as part of their wider construction contracts review.

  • Prefer conditional wording where the market allows it, so that a call requires a certificate, award or proof of loss rather than a bare demand.
  • Require prior notice to the contractor, for example a written notice a stated number of days before any demand, giving time to seek relief.
  • Limit the purpose of the bond to sums due under the contract, so a call for an unrelated project or a commercial dispute is plainly outside it.
  • Build in step-downs so the bonded amount reduces at practical completion or on issue of key certificates.
  • Fix a clear expiry date and resist automatic extension clauses or 'extend or pay' mechanisms without reasonable conditions.
  • Resist exclusion of unconscionability, or at least narrow it, given that CKR confirms such clauses are enforceable.
  • Address the return of excess sums, including interest, if the amount called exceeds the beneficiary's eventual entitlement.

Employers have the mirror-image interest in performance bond calls in Singapore: clear on-demand wording, a well-drafted exclusion clause and a disciplined internal process before calling. A beneficiary that calls only after documenting the breach and its loss, and that calls no more than it can justify, is far harder to restrain.

Illustrative scenario: a subcontractor facing a full call

This scenario is illustrative only and uses generic parties.

A specialist subcontractor provided an on-demand bank guarantee for a façade package. Near completion, the main contractor disputes the subcontractor's final account and, the same week, calls the full bond, citing alleged defects it had not previously raised. The subcontract contains no clause excluding unconscionability.

The subcontractor's advisers review correspondence showing that the main contractor had certified the relevant works without defect comments and had linked the call, in an email, to the final-account negotiation. They apply for an interim injunction within days, disclosing the defect allegations and the subcontractor's own delays, and offer an undertaking in damages. They also exhibit a quantity surveyor's estimate showing that any realistic rectification cost is a fraction of the bonded sum.

Whether such an application succeeds depends on the evidence, but the elements are those the courts look for: a call inconsistent with the beneficiary's earlier stance, an apparent ulterior purpose, and prompt, candid action by the applicant.

Risks and common mistakes

Applications to restrain performance bond calls in Singapore most often fail for avoidable reasons. These are the ones we see repeatedly.

Relying on a genuine dispute

Many applications fail because they show only that the obligor disputes the claim. A bona fide dispute about defects, delay or valuation does not make a call unconscionable; that is exactly the risk the bond allocates to the obligor.

Focus the evidence on why the call itself is abusive: the beneficiary's own breach, an inconsistent earlier position, an ulterior motive, or a demand grossly exceeding any arguable loss.

Ignoring an exclusion clause

Since CKR, a clause limiting relief to fraud is generally enforceable. An application framed only on unconscionability, without addressing the clause, invites dismissal and costs.

Read every layer of the contract. If exclusion is arguable, address it head-on; if it is clear, consider whether the facts genuinely support fraud.

Incomplete disclosure on a without-notice application

Urgency tempts applicants to present a one-sided story. The Court of Appeal in Bintai Kindenko held that an injunction should also have been discharged for failure to make full and frank disclosure.

Disclose the points against you, including your own defaults and the beneficiary's best arguments, and explain why the call is still abusive.

Moving too slowly

Delay can be fatal for practical reasons, because the bank may pay, and can undermine the claim of urgency. Every day spent negotiating informally after a call is a day the bank can honour it.

Prepare a playbook in advance for high-value projects, identifying who signs the affidavit and which documents are needed. For the wider security-of-payment position, see our guide to SOP adjudication in Singapore.

Cross-border bonds and next steps

Projects in Singapore frequently involve foreign contractors, foreign issuing banks and bonds governed by other laws. The governing law of the bond and the place where the bank pays both matter. A bond governed by English law may not attract Singapore's unconscionability exception in the same way, and an injunction from a Singapore court may need recognition or a parallel application where the bank is abroad.

Contractors from Bangladesh, the Middle East, China and elsewhere working in Singapore should check these points at the tender stage, not after a call. Our team coordinates with advisers in those jurisdictions and, where Singapore court representation is required, we work alongside Singapore-qualified counsel. Further reading: our construction disputes guide and our guide to urgent injunctions.

If a call has been made or threatened, time matters more than anything else. Contact our team with the bond, the demand and the contract, and we can help you assess quickly whether there is a viable application.

Frequently asked questions

01What makes a performance bond call unconscionable in Singapore?

As the Court of Appeal in BS Mount Sophia noted, citing earlier High Court authority, unconscionability involves unfairness, as distinct from dishonesty or fraud, or conduct so reprehensible or lacking in good faith that a court of conscience would intervene; mere breaches of contract are not enough. Examples include calls based on breaches the beneficiary caused itself, calls made for an ulterior purpose, calls inconsistent with its earlier position, and calls for sums well beyond any arguable loss. The obligor must show a strong prima facie case. A genuine dispute about whether the contractor is in breach is not enough, because that risk is what an on-demand bond allocates.

02Can a contract exclude the unconscionability exception?

Yes. In CKR Contract Services v Asplenium Land [2015] SGCA 24, the Court of Appeal upheld a clause providing that the contractor could not restrain a call on any ground except fraud. The court held that the clause limited the grounds of relief rather than ousting the court's jurisdiction. In a later decision, the Court of Appeal held that the party relying on such a clause bears the burden of showing that it applies. The clause in that case preserved fraud as a ground of relief.

03How quickly must I apply to stop a performance bond call?

Immediately. Banks usually pay promptly on a demand that complies with the bond, and an injunction granted after payment is of limited use. In practice, obligors often need to decide within a day whether there is a viable case and apply within a few days, sometimes without notice to the beneficiary. Preparing the evidence, an undertaking in damages and full and frank disclosure in that time is demanding, so contractors on large projects should plan their response before any call is made.

04Should the injunction be against the bank or the beneficiary?

Usually the main target is the beneficiary, restraining it from receiving payment under the bond, because the dispute about fraud or unconscionability concerns the beneficiary's conduct. The bank's undertaking is autonomous, and banks generally pay on a compliant demand unless restrained. Applicants often seek orders affecting both the beneficiary and the bank, and serve any order on the bank immediately. The right form of order depends on the bond, the parties and where payment is to be made.

05Does the beneficiary have to prove loss before calling an on-demand bond?

Not under a true on-demand bond. The bank pays on a demand that complies with the bond's terms, without proof of breach or loss, and the parties argue about entitlement later in arbitration or court. However, the size of the call relative to any realistic loss still matters. The Court of Appeal has recognised that a call for a sum well in excess of the beneficiary's actual or potential loss can cause unwarranted economic harm, and evidence of that kind can support an argument that the call is unconscionable, unless that ground has been excluded by contract.

06Is a conditional bond safer for contractors than an on-demand bond?

Generally, yes. A conditional or default bond requires the beneficiary to prove breach and loss, or produce a stated certificate, award or judgment, before payment. That gives the contractor more room to resist without relying on the narrow fraud and unconscionability exceptions. However, employers often insist on on-demand bonds, and the label on a bond is not decisive. What matters is the wording read as a whole, so contractors should review the instrument carefully at tender stage.

Sources and official materials

  1. JBE Properties Pte Ltd v Gammon Pte Ltd [2010] SGCA 46 — Unconscionability as an independent ground; rationale and typical bond size
  2. BS Mount Sophia Pte Ltd v Join-Aim Pte Ltd [2012] SGCA 28 — Court of Appeal on restraining calls on performance bonds
  3. CKR Contract Services Pte Ltd v Asplenium Land Pte Ltd [2015] SGCA 24 — Enforceability of clauses excluding the unconscionability ground
  4. Bintai Kindenko Pte Ltd v Samsung C&T Corp [2019] SGCA 39 — Burden on exclusion clauses; full and frank disclosure
  5. Civil Law Act 1909 — General power of the court to grant injunctions
  6. Clifford Chance: Singapore court examines calls on on-demand performance bonds — 2020 High Court decisions on unconscionability

General information only, current as at 20 October 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Singapore law and regulatory practice change; check current official sources and take advice on the facts of your matter.

TRW on LinkedIn & Facebook

From the firm,
this week.

Conference notes, transactions in the news and the people we work with — follow TRW & Co for the full feed.

Call the Singapore desk+880 1779 127165 WhatsApp · message usMessage our team